Comparison · Desktop program · Sourced facts
JDownloader Alternative: Save Streaming Videos Without a Java App
JDownloader 2 is a free, open-source desktop program; Vidora is a browser extension for the videos a page plays. What each one documents.
Quick answer
Keep JDownloader 2 if you want a free, open-source desktop program for batch downloads on Windows, macOS, Linux or a NAS. Choose Vidora (our product) when the video plays in a web page and you want to stay in the browser: it is a Chrome and Edge extension with nothing else to install, that saves HLS and DASH streams and decrypts AES-128 HLS. Both are free; the main Windows installer of JDownloader can include optional software offers.
Disclosure: we make Vidora, and its column comes from our own code.
JDownloader in one line
- JDownloader 2: Desktop program (Java) [1]; Chrome Web Store: No listing from the vendor found; the vendor states that its MyJDownloader extension is incompatible with current Chrome versions [2].
JDownloader vs Vidora: the full table
32 criteria, as in our multi-tool comparisons. A last group adds 2 criteria that the JDownloader 2 vendor documents outside that common set. Cells restate the vendor or the listing; Not documented and Not verified are never a No, since a well-known capability can be missing from the pages we read.
| Criterion | JDownloader 2 | Vidora (our product) |
|---|---|---|
| Type, platforms and price | ||
| Type | Desktop program (Java) [1] | Browser extension [3] |
| Browsers and systems | Windows, macOS, Linux, cross-platform JAR, NAS [1] | Chrome 116 or later; Edge (Edge Add-ons listing); no Firefox version [3] |
| Price | Free, open source [4] | Free today. A paid plan is planned; a free plan will stay available. [3] |
| Free version limits | No limit stated; optional software offers in the Windows installer [5] | No download limit today [3] |
| Extra application to install | Yes: it is a desktop program to install [6] | No [3] |
| Streaming formats and download features | ||
| HLS (m3u8) | Yes, with stated limitations [7] | Yes [3] |
| MPEG-DASH (mpd) | Not documented | Yes [3] |
| AES-128 encrypted HLS | Not documented | Yes [3] |
| Merges separate audio and video | Partial (through FFmpeg) [8] | Yes [3] |
| Quality choice | Yes [9] | Yes [3] |
| Live streams | Partial (stated: only partially supported) [7] | Partial [3] |
| Batch download | Yes [10] | Yes [3] |
| Subtitles | Not documented | Yes [3] |
| Audio only (MP3 or other) | Not documented | Yes [3] |
| YouTube, DRM, course platforms, privacy and ads | ||
| YouTube | Not documented | No [3] |
| DRM-protected content | Not supported [7] | Not supported [3] |
| Course platforms and private hosts | Not documented | Partial [3] |
| Local or server-side processing | Local (desktop program) [11] | Local [3] |
| Account required | No [12] | No [3] |
| Advertising | Optional software offers in the main Windows installer; an installer without offers exists [5] | No [3] |
| Chrome Web Store listing | ||
| On the Chrome Web Store | No listing from the vendor found; the vendor states that its MyJDownloader extension is incompatible with current Chrome versions [2] | Yes [13] |
| Users shown (Chrome Web Store) | Not applicable [2] | 1,000 [13] |
| Rating (Chrome Web Store) | Not applicable [2] | 4.8 out of 5 [13] |
| Number of ratings (Chrome Web Store) | Not applicable [2] | 12 [13] |
| Last update (Chrome Web Store) | Not applicable [2] | Nov 11, 2026 (version 1.0.88) [13] |
| Manifest V3 | No for the MyJDownloader extension (stated by the vendor) [14] | Yes [3] |
| Removal from a store | Not verified | None observed [13] |
| Edge Add-ons and Firefox Add-ons listings | ||
| On Edge Add-ons | Not verified | Yes [15] |
| Users (Edge Add-ons) | Not verified | 336 [16] |
| Rating (Edge Add-ons) | Not verified | 5.0 out of 5 (1 rating) [16] |
| Last update (Edge Add-ons) | Not verified | Nov 3, 2026 (version 1.0.87) [16] |
| On Firefox Add-ons | MyJDownloader extension announced for Firefox; Firefox Add-ons listing not read [6] | No [3] |
| Also documented for JDownloader 2 | ||
| Interface languages | Multilingual (number not verified) [10] | 30 [3] |
| Public source code | Yes (GPL) [10] | Not verified |
What the JDownloader vendor says, in its own words
- Type: “JDownloader 2 Choose your operating system: • Windows” [1]
- Browsers and systems: “Download MULTIOS JAR without dedicated Installer” [1]
- Price: “JDownloader is a free, open-source download management tool with a huge community” [4]
- Free version limits: “JDownloader can be free because we offer additional software offers during the installation process” [5]
- HLS (m3u8): “JDownloader can download HLS streams but there are a few limitations: Stopped HLS cannot be resumed” [7]
- Merges separate audio and video: “JDownloader makes use of FFmpeg for: websites which are using HLS streaming websites that are serving audio and video tracks separately mux-/demuxing of video and/or audio tracks” [8]
- Quality choice: “Many plugins provide quality settings which you can find in the Plugin Settings” [9]
- Live streams: “Downloading livestreams is only partially supported ny JDownloader.” [7]
- Batch download: “Download several files at once” [10]
- DRM-protected content: “In some cases, even the above described method may not work e.g. if the content you want to download: is DRM protected (= digital copy protection)” [7]
Where JDownloader is the better choice
- Open source. Its code is public under the GPL. Vidora's code is not public.
- Beyond the browser. It runs on Windows, macOS and Linux, as a multi-system JAR file and on a NAS, without a browser.
- Quality per site. Many of its plugins have their own quality settings, and it downloads several files at once.
On plain Yes, Partial and No values, no row puts JDownloader 2 ahead.
Where Vidora is the better choice
- Nothing to install outside the browser. JDownloader 2 is a desktop program. Vidora is an extension for Chrome 116 or later and Microsoft Edge.
- An extension that downloads. The JDownloader vendor declares its MyJDownloader browser extension incompatible with current Chrome versions. Vidora is listed on the Chrome Web Store and on Edge Add-ons.
- DASH and AES-128. Vidora downloads DASH streams and decrypts AES-128 HLS. The JDownloader pages we read document neither, which is not a No.
- Separate audio and video. Vidora merges them into one file. JDownloader 2 states partial support, through FFmpeg.
- No installer offers. The main Windows installer of JDownloader can contain optional software offers (an installer without offers exists). Vidora shows no ads.
On plain Yes, Partial and No values (a No counts as better for account, ads and extra application), Vidora is ahead on: Merges separate audio and video, Extra application to install. Vidora has a Yes where JDownloader 2 is Not documented or Not verified (not a No): MPEG-DASH (mpd), AES-128 encrypted HLS, Subtitles, Audio only (MP3 or other).
Other options, by what you download
- A paid Windows download manager. IDM pairs a Windows program with a browser extension: IDM compared with Vidora.
- YouTube. 4K Video Downloader Plus, another desktop program, documents YouTube playlists and channels: 4K Video Downloader Plus for YouTube playlists.
- A free extension for HLS and DASH. FetchV states no limit on its free use: FetchV against Vidora.
- Check your sites first. What works with Vidora, site by site: sites Vidora supports, with their limits.
To see desktop programs and extensions in the same tables, open the sourced comparison of 14 video downloaders; for extensions only, the video downloader extensions for Chrome compared one by one.
Switching from JDownloader
- Keep JDownloader 2 for the downloads that are not a video in a web page.
FAQ
Is JDownloader free?
Yes. JDownloader 2 is free and open source (GPL). Its main Windows installer can contain optional software offers; an installer without offers exists.
Does JDownloader have a Chrome extension?
Its vendor declares the MyJDownloader browser extension incompatible with current Chrome versions, since the switch to Manifest V3. We found no listing from the vendor on the Chrome Web Store.
Can JDownloader download HLS (m3u8) streams?
Yes, with limits its vendor states: for example, a stopped HLS download cannot be resumed. DASH is not documented on the pages we read. Vidora downloads HLS and DASH.
Can Vidora replace JDownloader?
Only for videos that play in a web page. Vidora is a video downloader for Chrome and Edge, not a general download manager for other kinds of files.
Does JDownloader download YouTube videos?
The JDownloader pages we read do not name YouTube, so the table says Not documented: a well-known capability can be missing from the pages we read. Vidora excludes YouTube.
Do I need an account?
No, for either. JDownloader needs an account only for MyJDownloader, which is optional. Vidora has no account at all.
Method, date and disclosure
12 JDownloader 2 pages and listings read on November 11, 2026; no hands-on test of JDownloader 2. Vidora: version 1.0.88, 1.0.87 on Edge. Anonymous usage counts are on by default (privacy policy); full method on the comparisons page; corrections: support.
Sources, read November 11, 2026
- JDownloader 2: jdownloader.org/download/index
- Chrome Web Store search for jdownloader
- Vidora: our own code and project files, version 1.0.88 (not public)
- JDownloader 2: jdownloader.org
- JDownloader 2: support.jdownloader.org/en/knowledgebase/article/software-offers-during-installation
- JDownloader 2: my.jdownloader.org/apps/
- JDownloader 2: support.jdownloader.org/en/knowledgebase/article/download-from-video-audio-streaming-websites
- JDownloader 2: support.jdownloader.org/en/knowledgebase/article/ffmpeg-installation-and-troubleshooting
- JDownloader 2: support.jdownloader.org/en/knowledgebase/article/audioimagevideo-quality-settings-and-behavior
- JDownloader 2: jdownloader.org/home/features
- JDownloader 2: support.jdownloader.org/en/knowledgebase/article/hls-streaming-downloads-and-related-problems
- JDownloader 2: support.jdownloader.org/en/knowledgebase/article/what-is-myjdownloader
- Vidora: Chrome Web Store listing
- JDownloader 2: support.jdownloader.org/en/knowledgebase/article/unable-to-install-myjdownloader-browser-extension-due-to-the-forced-switch-to-manifestv3
- Vidora: Edge Add-ons listing
- Vidora: Edge Add-ons listing data (public API)